WinterGold wrote:It is again (!!!) about drawing lines between different aspects of the same (!!!) sport.
I'm sorry but I don't agree with you.
But first I have to tell you that I have absolutely no experience with plates.
In my opinion the carving technique promoted by Swoard is a different sport than slalom races with plates; I'm sure you would agree if I tell you that half-pipe is not the same sport as snowboard carving, although somebody not well informed would tell you it's the same sport, snowboarding!
The extremecarving technique is about carving the steepest slopes as effortlessly as possible, controlling speed and eliminating all parasite gestures.
Racing technique is about going down flat slopes as fast as possible while turning around poles. Even if the technique is impressive, I would not say that it is aesthetically pleasing or fluid.
So of course the gear better suited to either technique is not the same; you wouldn't enter a snow park with modules using a carving board.
What Patrice is saying is that extreme carving is better done with dedicated gear and that plates are unnecessary (and he has tested them).
And an important point he mentioned is the price; the problem with alpine snowboarding is that youngsters are not attracted. If you add Kessler board 1500 euros, plate 1000 euros and Mountainslope boots 900 euros, the price will repulse any of them.
Whereas it is possible to do extremecarving with soft boots and a Dual board (have a look at Matti's latest video)... Which might raise interest in alpine boards.
So talking about extremecarving (which is the title of this forum), I don't see the problem if Patrice's point is that there is no need to complicate matters when you can have much fun without unnecessary stuff...