An unusual day... and an unusual balance.

Various topics, technical questions, announcements, events, resorts, ...

Moderators: fivat, rilliet, Arnaud, nils

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Post by RicHard » Monday 21 January 2008, 0:31

pokkis wrote:Me understand slightly less than zero about sking, and care even less, but why he must bend inside foot? why not keep it more straight caus ewith proper carve outside ski is anyway in air :D
If you keep the inside leg straight, how can you put the external on the snow?
Try to stand up and, without bending the right leg, lean with the whole body on the right to put the feet on their sides (as if the had their edge).
How can you do it if you don't bend the right leg? If you lean of 1cm, the left leg leave the ground of 1cm.
8O
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Post by RicHard » Monday 21 January 2008, 0:33

SuperHik wrote:About that last picture, skiers body position is totally wrong. It's center of gravity is way back.
Word of advice: move your arms forward, it'll push your center of gravity towards the center.
cheers.
Moving armsforwardwouldn't put so much weight toward the front and I see no other way to move weight forward, since the chest is already crashing on the knee.
In such extreme-carving turns, the standard rules of standard skiing are not appliable.
Cheers!
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

User avatar
Felix
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 669
Joined: Thursday 30 October 2003, 20:14
Location: Austria, but moedling near vienna, bloody 1 hour drive to semmering or rax
Contact:

Post by Felix » Monday 21 January 2008, 0:38

About Inside/Outside weight distribution.

It is impossible to increase inside ski pressure during the turn, every good skier/carver starts with much pressure on inside ski on turn initiation, to gradually move over the weigt to the outside ski. On even more increasing outside ski pressure you finally change directions and outside ski with full pressure becomes new inside ski.

If you wan't I can link to a german thread on a carving ski forum where several riders (professional ski teachers and ski racers) all adhere to that statement.
Swoard 3D - 168M
http://Openmtbmap.org - get the most popular maps for Mountainbiking in Europe...

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Post by RicHard » Monday 21 January 2008, 1:17

Felix wrote:About Inside/Outside weight distribution.

It is impossible to increase inside ski pressure during the turn, every good skier/carver starts with much pressure on inside ski on turn initiation, to gradually move over the weigt to the outside ski. On even more increasing outside ski pressure you finally change directions and outside ski with full pressure becomes new inside ski.

If you wan't I can link to a german thread on a carving ski forum where several riders (professional ski teachers and ski racers) all adhere to that statement.
Once again: all of you are talking about technique that is proper of STANDARD and MORE EFFICIENT way of skiing.
Extreme ski-carving is something different. You cannot apply standard rules when you are not doing anything that is considered standard.
:?
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

User avatar
pokkis
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1804
Joined: Monday 1 April 2002, 19:46
Location: Finland

Post by pokkis » Monday 21 January 2008, 8:06

RicHard wrote:
pokkis wrote:Me understand slightly less than zero about sking, and care even less, but why he must bend inside foot? why not keep it more straight caus ewith proper carve outside ski is anyway in air :D
If you keep the inside leg straight, how can you put the external on the snow?
Try to stand up and, without bending the right leg, lean with the whole body on the right to put the feet on their sides (as if the had their edge).
How can you do it if you don't bend the right leg? If you lean of 1cm, the left leg leave the ground of 1cm.
8O
Cause on ExtremeCarvSking all preasure is on inside ski, otherwise it just looks like silly ordinary looking sking :wink:
Outside ski is/should be on air 8)

H2O
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1874
Joined: Thursday 8 November 2007, 15:44
Location: Alagna - Milano

Re: Ski carving and the knees

Post by H2O » Monday 21 January 2008, 10:28

fivat wrote:Good picture! But arrrrgh :? for the knees!

All pressure on one knee at each turn... :alien: I have heard that many carving skiers have knees problems after a few seasons. After 15 years of intense extremecarving on snowboards (20 years in general), I still have no pain fortunately! 8)

Note that the snow conditions have a great importance. I'm afraid that one gets injured more easily with skis than with a snowboard when extreme carving...

Patrice Fivat
Patrice.....in fact I know about knees problems after many times of carving with ski, also in telemark!
RicHard, about the picture, of course, the skier isn't at 70%! but the balance point is supported by the weight on the tail of external ski.
A very beautiful picture, a very good rider, with the weight a little bit on the rear, is necessary a very strong action (also knees and abdomen muscles) for the next turn! I'd like to see the next turn.
Many years ago, to compensate the 2 skis different radius during a turn, Dynastar, for carving cup racers (to minimize the weight charges problems), produced skis with different internal/external radius, a good product but, unfortunately, not compatible with the in series production.
Also for telemark (and by now for normal ski), a handmaker in Colorado, ScottyBob, produces skis with different internal/external radius...I used them 4 years ago and during two winter seasons...very good!
RicHard, we can speak a lot in a good mountain reastaurant, after a good riding day (with a lot of snow) and...with a good red Italian wine.
Ciao ed alla prossima.
Pietro
Pietro
... sciare in pista è come nuotare in piscina, sciare in fuoripista è come farlo in mare aperto ...

SuperHik
Rank 2
Rank 2
Posts: 12
Joined: Tuesday 25 October 2005, 16:01
Location: Slovenia

Post by SuperHik » Monday 21 January 2008, 10:56

RicHard wrote:
SuperHik wrote:About that last picture, skiers body position is totally wrong. It's center of gravity is way back.
Word of advice: move your arms forward, it'll push your center of gravity towards the center.
cheers.
Moving armsforwardwouldn't put so much weight toward the front and I see no other way to move weight forward, since the chest is already crashing on the knee.
In such extreme-carving turns, the standard rules of standard skiing are not appliable.
Cheers!
If you push your arms forward, it'll automatically take your upper body with it, so you'll end up with center of gravity at the middle of the skies. as for the knees crashing in the chest, it's all connected.

This is happening , because skiers ass is to way back and he has to compensate by pushing his chest forward. When you have the correct possition on the skies, you can't (shouldn't) ever hit knees to the chest.


cheers

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Re: Ski carving and the knees

Post by RicHard » Monday 21 January 2008, 21:22

H2O wrote:RicHard, about the picture, of course, the skier isn't at 70%! but the balance point is supported by the weight on the tail of external ski.
That ski just grab the snow for 1mm... it can't guarantee any grip. That ski (for direct admission of the skier) has no pressure. It can just have pressure if you turn less than extreme. Otherwise... it's not an extreme turn.
:)
H2O wrote:A very beautiful picture, a very good rider, with the weight a little bit on the rear, is necessary a very strong action (also knees and abdomen muscles) for the next turn! I'd like to see the next turn.
I'll ask him the permission for posting a video (about him) I have got.
;)
H2O wrote:Many years ago, to compensate the 2 skis different radius during a turn, Dynastar, for carving cup racers (to minimize the weight charges problems), produced skis with different internal/external radius, a good product but, unfortunately, not compatible with the in series production.
I agree with you... it was a good idea, as far as I can understand...
H2O wrote:RicHard, we can speak a lot in a good mountain reastaurant, after a good riding day (with a lot of snow) and...with a good red Italian wine.
Ciao ed alla prossima.
Pietro
I hope we will do it soon!;)
A presto!
:D
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Post by RicHard » Monday 21 January 2008, 21:26

SuperHik wrote:When you have the correct possition on the skies, you can't (shouldn't) ever hit knees to the chest.
I disagree with you.
Of the two ones, choose just one: if you don't want the knee on the chest, you have to be with your weight too backward.
If you want to be centered, your chest as to short-circuit with your knee.
There's no chance to be so inclined keeping the internal leg straight and, since you have to beng it at the most, the chest has to compensategoing forward. Unfortunately... at a certain point...it crash on the knee...
;)
Can you show me a picture were a skier is "extremecarving" with the weight centered and the chest that doesn't almost touch the internal knee?
:?
Ciao!
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

JK moscraciun
Rank 0
Rank 0
Posts: 3
Joined: Wednesday 26 March 2008, 20:18
Location: Bucharest, Romania

Post by JK moscraciun » Wednesday 26 March 2008, 20:42

check these images taken by me in January 08 in Iscghl on the slope nr 21

my friend(former racer) was doing this carves in order to explain body alignment for some other skier!

he is not trying to extreme carve (he call’s it “the airplane” )

judging only by the snow spray from under his skis until some point 50/50 is a must

but when thing goes more extreme the 99% goes for the inside leg!

the knee in the chest doesn’t stop him to lean forward
Attachments
2.jpg
2.jpg (107.5 KiB) Viewed 4742 times
1.jpg
1.jpg (93.77 KiB) Viewed 4749 times

User avatar
RicHard
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tuesday 16 April 2002, 14:35
Location: Italy

Post by RicHard » Thursday 27 March 2008, 9:36

I don't understand why the right arm has to be so high (second picture). It put less weight on the edges than keeping it along the leg...
8O
_RicHard
Kessler The Alpine 168 - FTWO Speester RS Proto 179 (2012) - Burton Fire boots

User avatar
kurtsk8
Rank 5
Rank 5
Posts: 2681
Joined: Saturday 30 December 2006, 10:44

Post by kurtsk8 » Thursday 27 March 2008, 9:48

JK moscraciun wrote:he is not trying to extreme carve (he call’s it “the airplane” )
if the arm would not be so high it would be an airplane with a broken wing :)
"I miei sci sbattono, vibrano, sbandano. Io no."

JK moscraciun
Rank 0
Rank 0
Posts: 3
Joined: Wednesday 26 March 2008, 20:18
Location: Bucharest, Romania

Post by JK moscraciun » Thursday 27 March 2008, 10:57

RicHard wrote:I don't understand why the right arm has to be so high (second picture). It put less weight on the edges than keeping it along the leg...
8O
he is just having fun and making a point about shoulder/hip alignment, inclination vs angulation etc for other skiers! not trying to extreme carve in a way to imitate a snowboarder!

+ my post is trying to prove that if you extreme carve on skis you going to end up on one ski!

Locked